Strategic Quitting: The Art of Winning by Knowing When to Fold

The idea of quitting often conjures up thoughts of failure or giving up. We hear the PE teachers in our earhole telling us winners never quit and quitters never win. It's ingrained is us to never, never, never give up. Do not throw in the towel however much you're getting beaten. However, in the realm of business and personal growth, and indeed in pretty much every area of life, strategic quitting can be the most astute decision, emblematic of foresight and strong leadership.

We choose to quit every day. Quit sleeping when we get up; quit cleaning our teeth when we think they are done; quit driving when we reach our destination.

So, when it comes to big decisions, why is it so difficult to quit?

Annie Duke, author and former poker player said this:

"Grit is great. Sometimes you see something that other people don’t see. But sometimes when the world is yelling at you to stop and you ignore them, that’s no longer a virtue. Then it’s folly.”

I haven't read Annie's book (Quit: The Power of Knowing When To Walk Away) but it's on the Christmas list! She does have a brilliant conversation on the HBR podcast, which you can listen to below.

Quitting can be a powerful tool, even a calculated move that aligns with long-term success and personal wellbeing.

It's not about abandoning ship at the first sign of trouble. Instead, it's a deliberate decision, made after careful analysis and consideration, acknowledging that the current path may no longer lead to the desired destination. It's about making choices that are in line with your core values, life goals, and current circumstances.

Knowing When to Quit
The critical question then becomes: when is the right time to quit? The answer lies in a continuous assessment of progress against goals and the current landscape – be it market trends, personal relationships, or professional trajectories. Quitting becomes a strategic choice when:

Continued efforts yield diminishing returns: When more effort, time, or resources no longer lead to proportional benefits or growth, it may be time to reassess and consider quitting that particular course of action.

Core values or goals have shifted: Personal and professional growth often involves evolving goals and values. If your current efforts no longer align with these, quitting can be a way to realign with what truly matters.

Wellbeing is compromised: If persistence in a particular path is causing undue stress, burnout, or affecting health, strategically quitting can be necessary for long-term wellbeing. And this might not just be your wellbeing; it might be that of those around you like your partner, children or colleagues.

‍

Knowing How to Quit
If you have decided it's time to quit, often it's thinking about the practicalities. In business, this might mean

1. Product Line Rationalisation: Companies often expand their product lines to capture more market share. However, a bloated product portfolio can dilute your brand identity and strain resources. Strategic quitting in this context involves identifying underperforming or non-core products and discontinuing them. This approach allows a company to concentrate resources on products that are profitable and core to its brand identity.

2. Market Exit Decisions: Businesses sometimes enter new markets with high hopes, but factors like intense competition, regulatory challenges, or misaligned market needs can lead to poor performance. Strategic quitting involves recognising when a market is no longer viable and withdrawing to focus on more promising opportunities.

3. Innovation and Pivoting: In the tech industry, companies often start with one idea but pivot to another after assessing market response and potential. This kind of strategic quitting – abandoning the original concept for a more viable one – can be the difference between failure and becoming a market leader. More on pivoting in future newsletter editions.

But for many of us, it isn't always business decisions that we need to quit per se; we likely need to do some quitting in our personal lives. What things might we need to look at?

Career Changes Professionally, strategic quitting might look like leaving a stagnant or unfulfilling job to pursue a career that aligns better with your passions, values, or goals. This decision often requires weighing the security of the current position against the potential for greater satisfaction and growth in a new role.

Educational Paths Students might begin a course of study only to realise that it doesn't align with their interests or career aspirations. Strategic quitting here means recognising this misalignment early and shifting to a field of study that is more in line with their aspirations and strengths. Steven Bartlett is great at talking about this on his DOAC podcast (he quit university within the first few weeks and his parents didn't speak to him!)

Relationships On a personal level, strategic quitting can also apply to relationships and commitments. This might involve ending relationships that are harmful or no longer fulfilling, or stepping back from commitments that do not contribute to personal growth or wellbeing. This is often hard - you can't walk away from some relationships - but it might be the thing you need most. If you want to see your future, look at the company you keep.

In both business and personal contexts, strategic quitting involves a careful evaluation of the risks and rewards. It requires balancing potential losses of continuing what you're doing against the possibility of greater rewards from new ventures or paths. This decision-making process is often complex and requires not just a consideration of tangible factors like finances or time but also intangible elements like job satisfaction, personal growth, and overall happiness.

In practice, strategic quitting is about making informed decisions that prioritise long-term over short-term and avoiding the inertia of staying the course. Whether in business or personal life, it's a deliberate, thoughtful process. It's acknowledging that change is about making proactive decisions that are in line with where you or your business need to be, not where you have been. Strategic quitting can open the door to new opportunities so far from being a sign of failure, it's an indication of maturity, foresight, and the courage to pursue a path that leads to who you wish to become.

Here's to the strategic quitters!

‍